TheBookScene.com bookscene at gmail.com
Sun Dec 28 20:21:28 EST 2008

None of those facts, singularly or as a group, seem enough for a compelling
doubt, to me.

In fact, reason number 3 may tend to support the authenticity of the
signature. I can see an author presenting a signed copy to his wife of his
very 1st work at the time of first publication. Or a copy of a later work
that she had a connection or made a contribution to. Any other work signed
in this fashion would possibly indicate a separation?


On Sun, Dec 28, 2008 at 5:27 PM, JOSEPH HILL <goodbooks at webtv.net> wrote:

>  Last week I sold a Modern Library Price Guide to a collector of first
> editions who specializes in Fitzgerald; why he wanted a copy of the Guide, I
> have no idea.
> He stated that he has three inscribed Modern Library editions of the
> Gatsby.
> I then told him of the inscribed copy to his wife that I had seen at a San
> Francisco book show with my eldest daughter some thirty years ago.
> He then gave me the following reasons why that copy may well be a fake.
> 1,) No major Fitzgerald collector  knows of its existence.
> 2.) Even thirty years ago, the price of $1,600 would be  low.
> 3.) At the time the Modern Library edition was published (1934), Zelda was
> already institutionalized.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://thuban.owu.edu/pipermail/modlib/attachments/20081228/9a96a618/attachment.html

More information about the ModLib mailing list