Gordon Neavill aa3401 at
Tue Sep 2 09:48:54 EDT 2003

The Commager introduction replaced Goodman's in 1944.  This is also a
different typesetting from the 1932 edition.  A bibliography was added in
1950 when the Franklin was added to MLCE and the title page was partially
reset with Commager's title and affiliation added.

----- Original Message -----
From: "John Wolansky" <jwol at>
To: "Mod Lib List Serve" <modlib at>
Sent: Tuesday, September 02, 2003 8:30 AM

> I vaguely recall some discussion on this board about an edition with
> introductory material from someone other than Goodman; however, Scott does
> not have a second edition on his Guide updates, so ...  While I archive
> ML listserve material, my system crashed and I lost everything.
> Toledano indicates only one Franklin edition, 39.2 with Goodman.  I have a
> copy with an introduction by Henry Commager and no reference to Goodman.
> Is this an unreported edition?
> John Wolansky
> jwol at

More information about the ModLib mailing list