Warning for New Collectors: Beware of 1st Edition Claims
aa3401 at wayne.edu
Thu Nov 8 10:43:15 EST 2001
And quite a few printings with "First ML Edition" statements on the verso of
the title page aren't!
----- Original Message -----
From: Scot Kamins <kamins at dogeared.com>
To: ML LIstServ <modlib at algol.owu.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, November 06, 2001 2:05 PM
Subject: Warning for New Collectors: Beware of 1st Edition Claims
> New collectors,
> As of late I have noticed an apparent increase in the number of ML copies
> advertised as Firsts on eBay. But in fact many books on eBay listed as
> first modern library editions are later editions.
> Sometimes this is because the lister makes assumptions about how to tell
> if a book is a first edition, sometimes it's because the lister has made
> an honest mistake, and sometimes the lister is simply a scoundrel.
> Here are some ways to protect yourself, both on eBay and in general:
> ? Check the listed first edition points against the Toledano Guide.
> ? If the points aren't listed, ask the seller for information - DO NOT
> BUY IN A VACUUM.
> ? Ask here - that's one of the reasons this group exists!
> ? Buy from a reputable dealer. I guarantee the integrity of the following
> dealer-members of this listServ, all of whom from time to time or
> regularly list books on eBay. If they make a mistake and sell you a book
> that turns out NOT to be an advertised first edition, they'll make it
> Sharon Biederman (sbiederm at nova.umuc.edu)
> Amy Comeau
> Sam Gottlieb
> Joe Hill (goodbooks at webtv.net)
> Henry Toledano
> Scot Kamins
> Maintaining the Modern Library Collecting Website at
> which (in turn) is supported by The Pavilion City Mall at
More information about the ModLib